Big Engagement Ring Debate: Costco vs. Shane Co vs. James Allen
3 min

Big Engagement Ring Debate: Costco vs. Shane Co vs. James Allen

engagement ring stores

Are you ready to take the next step and purchase the perfect engagement ring? With numerous options available, we’ve evaluated three of the most popular websites to help you make an informed decision.

When considering where to buy an engagement ring, it’s crucial to weigh several key criteria to ensure a wise and meaningful purchase. We’ve assessed Costco, Shane Co, and James Allen based on the following three essential factors, assigning scores to each. Ultimately, select a jeweler that aligns with your values and your partner’s preferences.

  1.  Quality and Certification: Seek a jeweler with high-quality, certified gemstones, such as those graded by the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) or the International Gemological Institute (IGI). Certification ensures authenticity and accurate grading.
  2. Customer Reviews and Reputation: Research the jeweler’s reputation by seeking out customer reviews and testimonials. A reputable jeweler should have a history of customer satisfaction and ethical practices.
  3. Customer Service and Warranty: Assess the jeweler’s customer service. Are they knowledgeable and helpful? Check for warranties or guarantees, which provide peace of mind and protection in case of issues.

Additionally, consider factors like return policies, customization options, and additional services like resizing and maintenance. It’s vital to compare prices from different jewelers to ensure you get a fair deal.

If a purchase is made from the links provided, Wed Mayhem may receive a commission.


Quality and Certification:

At Costco, they maintain strict standards for diamonds based on GIA criteria. Their team of Gemologists, all GIA graduates, scrupulously examines diamonds for quality, color, clarity, cut, and carat weight. Costco guarantees diamonds to be “VS2” or better in clarity and “I” or better in color, selling only diamond cut grades from Very Good to Excellent. Costco exclusively sells untreated diamonds.

Customer Reviews and Reputation:

Costco is known for offering good quality engagement rings, especially when the diamond is GIA certified. However, there are alternative options that may be more preferable.

Customer Service and Warranty:

While Costco employees can assist in opening the case, they may not provide specialized jewelry guidance. Costco offers returns for a refund, including shipping and handling fees, with a straightforward process.

Shane Co

Quality and Certification:

Shane Co offers loose natural diamonds, including Shane Classic diamonds, as well as loose lab-grown diamonds. The loose natural diamonds are conflict-free and meticulously sourced. They’re cherished for their rarity, formed deep within the earth over billions of years. Shane Co.’s Natural Diamonds Are All Conflict-Free and Ethically Sourced. They also offer high-quality loose lab-grown diamonds, cut to maximize sparkle. These diamonds provide exceptional quality and great value, created with cutting-edge science and technology.

Customer Reviews and Reputation:

Initially, Shane Co appears to be a reliable option for jewelry shopping, offering a beautiful selection of diamond engagement rings and promising attentive customer service. However, some customers have reported dissatisfaction, particularly with fluctuating prices that weren’t transparently communicated upfront, extra fees added during checkout, and concerns about diamond quality.

Customer Service and Warranty:

  • Free 2-day shipping
  • Ethically sourced
  • Free Lifetime Warranty
  • 60-day money-back guarantee (Free in-store and online returns)

James Allen

Quality and Certification:

James Allen only purchases diamonds from members of the professional diamond trade, ensuring that every diamond sold is certified conflict-free and complies with international regulations. They offer an extensive inventory of over 315,000 natural diamonds and more than 50,000 lab-grown diamonds, all certified by leading independent diamond labs.

Customer Reviews and Reputation:

Since their establishment in 2006, James Allen has continuously innovated to become one of the premier diamond engagement ring retailers worldwide. Their relentless pursuit of creating the perfect online jewelry store has solidified their reputation.

Customer Service and Warranty:

All jewelry purchased from James Allen is eligible for a free cleaning every six months. They also offer free prong tightening, re-polishing, rhodium plating, and cleaning services. James Allen stands behind every item they sell and provides a lifetime warranty, covering manufacturing defects. In case any other services are required, charges are transparently communicated prior to work being done to service your jewelry.

In the quest for the perfect engagement ring, the choice is no small matter. While all three jewelers, Costco, Shane Co, and James Allen, have their unique merits, and each bring something unique to the table in short conclusion: 

Costco:  If you love a good deal and quality, they’ve got it. Just don’t ask them for jewelry fashion advice!

Shane Co:  Beautiful rings are their jam, but be prepared for pricing surprises.

James Allen: A diamond lover’s paradise with top-notch service. It’s innovation meets bling-tastic!

Ultimately, the choice boils down to what sparkles best for you and your wallet! 💍💫

Meet Your Wedding Wingman!

Subscribe To Get Your Wedding Planning Checklist!

Unsubscribe from newsletter at any time.

7 min

Engagement Rings Settings: Find Your Forever Match

Engagement Ring Settings

You’ve heard it before, make sure to choose an engagement ring you’ll really love. In order to do this, it all comes down to choosing your favorite ring setting and communicating with your partner on what wedding ring you want.

The settings refers to how the gemstones are mounted onto the metal of the engagement ring. There are many different options ranging from simplistic to flashy.  If you need a little extra FYI we have some extra tips and tricks for choosing the “yes” ring.

Remember that before considering your preferred engagement ring setting to first decide:

  • Size—What is your wedding band size? You want your forever ring to fit just right!
  • Preferred metals like platinum or gold—Everyone has a specific personal taste. Do you wear gold or platinum jewelry more often? Which metal is more appealing to you?
  • Gemstone cut and stone type—Do you have a preference on the amount of sparkle of your diamond? Do you want or need a more durable stone?
  • Budget—How much are you willing to spend on your wedding ring setting?

Next, it all comes down to aesthetics, so be prepared to search until you find what is exactly perfect. To begin, we are going to run down the different styles of engagement ring settings to help make sure you can make the right choice. 

If a purchase is made from the links provided, Wed Mayhem may receive a commission. Prices reflect the date posted, refer to company website for up to date pricing.

Solitaire Engagement Ring

The lone soldier ring and the most simplistic engagement ring setting is the Solitaire. The name Solitaire refers to the single diamond the setting carries. For a classy woman, the diamond is set high to enhance its exposure to light. This allows for every angle of the gemstone to show itself off, creating the perfect mix between simplicity, perfection and sparkle.

Halo Engagement Ring

The halo style ring is rising as the new classic. The name comes from a single gemstone lined with smaller diamonds in a halo style shape. The combination of the two creates a larger looking diamond with endless twinkle. This setting is perfect for the trendy woman who wants the sparkle to be supreme. 

Three-Stone Engagement Ring

A ring that screams symbolism. The three gemstones that make up the setting of this engagement band have a specific meaning: representing your past, present, and future together. The middle gemstone is usually the largest to increase the look of depth. This ring is perfect for sentimental women who cherish the memories and milestones of their relationships.

Pavé Engagement Ring

A setting style that almost erases the presence of the metal ring. The diamonds are set close together to create a solid diamond surface. The ring itself provides an experience to any viewer. A subtle statement ring, this setting is for the woman that adores her diamonds and wow-factor.

Swirl Engagement Ring

Similar to the infinity setting, this setting creates a “swirl” like formation around the center diamond. A ring that screams feminine and playful, this engagement ring setting is perfect for the lively woman.

Choosing the perfect ring for her is not impossible. Learn her likes and dislikes and you’ll be able to narrow down the perfect ring setting for your bride-to-be! Each ring setting is unique in its own way and you are bound to wow your future wife with any ring you take the time to hand-pick. 

Classic Engagement Ring

Like the name suggests, the classic style setting is timeless. Often a combination of Pavé and Solitaire settings, the classic engagement ring is always a win with any woman. The gemstones are set to compliment each other rather than over power. It is hard to go wrong with a classic style setting. This setting is for the woman that adores her sparkle and wants the diamonds to compliment each other. 

Infinity Engagement Ring

As the name suggests, this wedding band creates an infinity sign by the intertwining of the metal. It is meant to symbolize the connection between the husband and wife. As a symbolic ring, this setting is great for the woman who loves visual symbolism and wants to emphasize her forever commitment. 

Cathedral Engagement Ring

In this style, the diamond is nested between two bands on either side. It is firmly placed so that it draws attention. The diamond is secured which is great for any woman who may be worried about the delicacy of her ring. This setting style is great for any woman that is a fan-favorite of simplicity or is someone who works with their hands.

Vintage Engagement Ring

Acting as a combination between timeless design and contemporary setting styles, the vintage setting is hard to pass up. A setting that comes in numerous styles and options is great for any woman that likes a little classic style with a bit of contemporary twist. If she is all about waging slightly away from traditional settings like classic or solitaire, then vintage may be her style.

Channel-Set Engagement Ring

In a fresh style setting, the channel-set design is perfect for the modern woman who wants a bit of extra bling and uniformity. The combination of the embedded diamonds and an eye-catching diamond centerpiece, this ring is bound to turn heads. 

Subscribe To Get Your Wedding Planning Checklist!

Unsubscribe from newsletter at any time.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Nothing Yet

Be the first one to comment!

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.